Leland, After having time to gather my thoughts and reflect on the tournament, it was a worthwhile endeavor.  I learned that team play is possible in tournament chess, even among many "ego-centric" chessplayers.  We did have a problem with a "malcontent," but I've learned that he did not want to play even before coming to the tournament.  Attitude is everything, and speaking of attitude, I can't be more impressed with the N.C. players for their sportsmanship and willingness to adapt to the unusual tournament format that we created literally "on the fly".  I've had good experiences in the past directing in N.C. (this year's LPO, for instance) and I appreciate the N.C. players' excellent sports- manship and impeccable behavior during tournament play.  It is a true reflection on the quality of the scholastic programs and chess instructors within the state of N.C. as well as the organizers at all levels. One comment about participation is that the overall state points are not only a reflection of wins and losses, but also on participation.  Byes count toward the total score and if you don't have a player in the section, you'll receive no bye.  Thus, turnout is a major factor in winning the Carolinas Challenge Cup.  That being said, N.C. has an inherent advantage and should never allow attendence to be its downfall. I openly hope that many of the participants will give constructive feedback to you so that you'll be encouraged to have the 2nd Carolinas Challenge next year.  This tournament could be fixture in Carolina's chess and actually gain local, regional and national attention.  The critical factor will be perfecting the format so that all players will feel its fair and manageable within their tournament schedule.  Suggestions about pairings, round schedules, time controls, prizes, entry fees, sites, or anything should be proposed by all and considered for future tournaments.  I hope that players from both states will give you feedback and encouragement to pursue this worthwhile event in the future. Thank you for allowing me to be a part of this exciting endeavor. Sincerely, David Causey